← Back to home

Why does the ISA-101 style look so gray and washed out vs traditional HMIs?

HMI & SCADA design @pauserranoAdvanced4633 viewsEnglish
My plant manager looked at an ISA-101 mockup and asked why it's "so dull" compared to our old FactoryTalk screens that are full of bright green pipes, red tanks and blue water. He thinks the gray version looks unfinished.

How do I justify the calm gray palette to someone used to saturated process graphics? Is there real evidence it's better, or is it just a style preference?

1 answer

It isn't a style preference, it's a signal-to-noise argument. If everything on the screen is saturated, then color carries no information: a real alarm doesn't stand out because the green pipe next to it is just as loud. ISA-101 pushes the normal state to low-contrast grays specifically so that the only saturated color on the screen is an abnormal condition, which the eye finds instantly.

The canonical background is a mid gray (~#C8C8C8) with white for operative areas. Equipment is drawn in grayscale. You reserve red/orange/yellow/blue strictly for alarm priorities and green/gray for run/stop. Nothing is colored just because it's water or gas.

The way to sell it to management: put the two screens side by side and trigger one alarm on each. On the busy screen people hunt for it; on the calm screen it jumps out. That demo wins the argument every time.

Background on the philosophy is in /standards/isa-101.html and the exact palette with hex values is in /learn/hmi-color-palette.html
@pauserranoAdvanced463 Accepted answer

← Back to the forum